Elke from Germany: What is the best dog a border collie would get along with?
I have a 4 month old border collie male and we were thinking about getting another dog but we dont want to get another border collie.
we have a big property so it cant be a really small dog.
whats the best dog that would get along with our border collie?
Photo Credit: bambe1964/Flickr CC
Answers and Views:
Answer by Amerz & The Labradork
Aussie's have a similar energy level and disposition.
Answer by Tony
Border collies are active dogs, so I would get a rough collie because they are completely opposite. Most collie lines are calm, gentle, and love everyone ( including the guy robbing your house, not a watchdog). The downfall is a high maintenance coat, but that's completely Worth the trouble for that wonderful temperament. originally breed for herding, most lines are now breed for show or pet and have lost that active, high ENERGY instinct, especially when they've been spay or neutered.
Answer by marci knows best
I agree a dog in the herding group would be the best bet. I would suggest waiting a few months so the puppy has time to bond with you and learn the ropes so to speak. Otherwise the puppies will bond with each other and not with you.
Answer by Pixie
I have had several requests lately from families that just got their l puppy and now that it is 14-20 weeks old…they love it so much they just HAVE to have another one and would like to rescue. Most of them get mad and think I’m calling them bad dog parents when I deny their application and I am not. They don’t even listen to my reasons for denying them at the current time. Some people just got a puppy of a different breed and just want to have two puppies at the same time because they think it will make life easier to housebreak two at the same time and they can keep each other entertained. That’s the lazy way to raise puppies – letting them raise each other and it will come back to bite you.
Adopting two puppies of ANY breed is a bad idea just as it is a bad idea to adopt siblings or same sex puppies. Honestly, I think the worst mistake someone could make is getting two same sex littermates. The best idea is to have each puppy bond and be trained by the family as they enter the home separately. A responsible breeder will want you to have your dog raised, trained and neutered before adding another.
It is in a puppy’s best interest to enter a family that does not have another puppy and can dedicate time to his/her training and development, not expect two puppies to entertain each other and raise each other. That is the surest way to have behavior problems. The puppies would bond to each other instead of the family. They would be more difficult to train because they are not that bonded to people. They would be more “doggie” than a dog that entered the home separately. When the dogs begin to socially mature, they would likely have problems with competition because of their close age, those that are the same sex usually start having problems getting along as they try and assert their dominance with each other.
Adopting puppies that are one to two years apart will reduce competition and tensions that come when dogs are beginning to socially mature and test their dominance boundaries with each other. A Border Collie is a very hands on breed and needs the time and attention and structure that a multiple puppy home will not provide.
Know better? Give your own answer to this question!
Karen Wrona says
Hello,
You might want to try an Icelandic Sheepdog. I have a rescue mix from the National Rescue group. Live in Michigan, got him from Utah. Found on the border of Idaho and Utah. Amazing dog, great with other dogs. High energy, but can go low as well. About 45 lbs of muscle, plays catch and frisbee, loves squeaky toys, affectionate, easy to train. Can jump over anything on command. Very little grooming needed. The breed can be barky, as that is how they herd, but he is pretty quiet unless it is dinner time.
Dermot Darin says
I have a 3 yr old border collie. Off the lead he is a dream. After lots of training he still pulls on the lead. Luckily I live 100yrds from the beach so its not a major problem. He is so submissive he will give his ball away. Any collie owener will understand this. When he sees a husky he goes mental and agressive towards it. I speculate but realy dont know why. I have him from 12 weeks and has never had husky trauma. I wonder if its the wolf look of them?
Any ideas welcome.
Viktoria says
umm.. well i've been searching online for a husky puppy & i've seen ALOT of husky cross border collies.. So i guess they get along pretty well..
SoccerRefToo says
Minako
There is no way to tell. Don't thrust your desires on your dog. If you are getting another family dog you should do a little research on breeds you like and that are both family and dog friendly. Then go and see if you can find an adoptable dog that is acceptable to both you AND your dog. See if the kennel or foster home will let you take the dog home and keep them together for a few days to make sure they get along.
Just like some people don't get along, some dogs too will never get along. Sometimes from the moment they meet there is friction; so make it a family project, dog included, to find a new pal.
Good Luck!
Soccerref
Ally says
I agree, get an aussie or maybe a blue healer. A herding dog will think similarly and make sure they have similar energy levels
hercule says
"The great" labrador retrievers are the best dogs in the world. i have one trained lab and i think it is the best dog. it can get along with other dogs very easily. this species is also ranked no.1 by the American kennel club(akc) .